Sal's Authentic NY Pizza - Beach Street
4.2 281 pizza restaurant Expect the full New York pizzeria experience at Sal's, New Zealand's only 100% authentic New York pizza. -45.032591599999996 168.65840849999998?
About this score
A weighted average across available review sources.
Expect the full New York pizzeria experience at Sal's, New Zealand's only 100% authentic New York pizza.
What to Order
Menu Highlights
New Hawaiian
Free range champagne ham, organic pineapple and premium NYC blend mozzarella
New Pepperoni
Sal's legendary sauce, premium NYC blend mozzarella and our famous New York pepperoni
New Meatball
Authentic beef and oregano meatballs
New Buffalo Chicken
Breaded free range chicken breast, buffalo sauce and blue cheese sauce
New Garlic Knots
$3.50 each, 3 for $8, 8 for $153x Knots, Crushed Garlic, EVOO
New Zeppole
Sal's signature dough, fried golden brown, tossed in cinnamon and sugar, and generously powdered with icing sugar with the choice of vanilla custard, chocolate, or raspberry coulis dipping sauce
What People Say
"Overall, a satisfying and flavourful pizza that I’d definitely go back for."
Reviewers consistently praise the delicious and flavourful pizzas, along with the enjoyable atmosphere and good crust.
"The ones from Wellington were better, but I still rate 5 stars. It is a bit overpriced (half pizza) on UberEats so they kind of force you to order a full pizza (for the actual price)."
"Tried the 5 Boroughs pizza at Sal’s and really enjoyed it! The crust was spot on - crispy yet light, just like a proper New York slice. The mix of sauces and toppings worked well together without being too heavy. Overall, a satisfying and flavourful pizza that I’d definitely go back for."
The Vibe
More pizza restaurants in Queenstown
ITALIAN WAY - Pizza, Beers and More
4.9(277)pizza restaurant · Frankton
At Italian Way, everything starts with the preparation of our signature dough, the secret behind a pizza full of flavour and an unbeatable crust. Each pizza is stretched to order by our skilled chefs.
246 reviews
Fat Badgers Pizza Bar Queenstown
4.4(2,307)pizza restaurant · Queenstown 9300
At Fat Badgers, we don’t cut corners - unless it's into massive pizza slices. Every base is hand-stretched, every topping piled high, and every bite crafted to satisfy.
2,103 reviews
Winnies
4.4(6,264)pizza restaurant · Queenstown 9348
Relaxed, pizza-centric joint & happening bar featuring dancing & DJs later in the evening.
3,892 reviews
Last reviewed April 2026 · Suggest an edit
Owner of Sal's Authentic NY Pizza - Beach Street? Claim this listing